To compare two senior roles properly, score each one on seven dimensions: expertise, experience, successes, flow, vision, organisation fit and package. Salary and title belong to the last of the seven. The other six decide whether you will do well in the role and whether it takes you where you want to go.
This guide explains each dimension, shows a worked comparison and sets out how to read the result.
Why Salary and Title Mislead
Salary and title are the easiest things to compare, so they get the most weight. They say little about whether the role uses what you are best at, whether you can prove you can do it, or whether the organisation will let you succeed. Many senior moves that disappoint looked like clear steps up on both measures.
The Seven Dimensions
Score each role from 1 to 5 on each dimension.
| Dimension | The Question to Ask |
|---|---|
| Expertise | How much of the role draws on skills you can already demonstrate? |
| Experience | Have you worked at this scope, in this kind of organisation or sector? |
| Successes | Do your past results match what this role needs delivered? |
| Flow | Will the daily work be the kind you do best and find most absorbing? |
| Vision | Does the role move you towards the career you have decided you want? |
| Organisation Fit | Do the culture, the manager and the way decisions are made suit how you work? |
| Package | Is the total reward right: salary, bonus, equity, pension, flexibility and location? |
The first three are about your evidence. The next two are about your direction. The last two are about the employer and the terms.
Choose Your Weights First
Before you score anything, decide which two dimensions matter most to you at this point in your career, and write them down. Someone five years from retirement may weight package and organisation fit. Someone rebuilding after a difficult role may weight flow and vision.
Doing this first stops you adjusting the weights afterwards to justify the answer you already wanted.
A Worked Example
This example is illustrative and not a real person.
A marketing director is choosing between two offers. Role A is Group Marketing Director at a large listed company, with a higher salary and a bigger title. Role B is Chief Marketing Officer at a smaller private firm, with a lower salary, equity and a seat on the leadership team. She has decided that vision and flow matter most to her.
| Dimension | Role A | Role B |
|---|---|---|
| Expertise | 5 | 4 |
| Experience | 5 | 3 |
| Successes | 4 | 4 |
| Flow | 2 | 5 |
| Vision | 3 | 5 |
| Organisation Fit | 3 | 4 |
| Package | 5 | 3 |
| Total | 27 | 28 |
The totals are almost equal, so the total does not decide it. The pattern does.
Role A scores highest where she is already proven and lowest on the work itself. Most of the job is managing agencies and reporting upward, which she has done for years and no longer finds absorbing. Role B scores lowest on experience, because she has not held a board-level role, and highest on the two dimensions she chose as most important.
She takes Role B. The low experience score becomes her preparation list: she asks for a clear set of first-year priorities and arranges a mentor who has made the same step.
How to Read the Scores
- Look at the lowest scores before the total. A 1 or 2 on organisation fit is a warning that a high package rarely makes up for.
- Check your two weighted dimensions. If a role scores under 3 on either, ask what would have to change for you to accept it.
- Treat low evidence scores as questions. A low score on experience or successes may mean a real gap, or a result you have not yet written down.
- Be wary of a role that scores 5 on everything you have done before. It may be the same job again.
Questions That Firm Up Your Scores
You will not have enough information from the job description. Ask:
- Who held the role before, and why is it open?
- What would success look like after 12 months?
- How are decisions made, and who has the final say on the budget?
- What has the person I would report to changed their mind about recently?
- What is the one thing that would make this role fail?
Rescore after each conversation. The scores should move as you learn more.
When the Scores Tie
If two roles are level on the total and on your weighted dimensions, compare the worst case for each. Ask which role you would rather be in if the first year went badly. Then ask which would be easier to leave with your reputation and options intact.
Where to Start
Scoring is quicker and more honest when your evidence is already written down. Career Designer builds a Career Profile from your CV and LinkedIn text, then scores target roles against it and compares them side by side. See the platform, or take the Career Design Assessment to see where you stand first.